Shunkan & Kikaigashima

Home / Shunkan & Kikaigashima

07 — Literature

Left behind,
alone on the island.

Iwo-jima (Mishima Village), part of the outer rim of the Kikai Caldera, where Mt. Io-dake still smokes to this day, is said to be the traditional site of "Kikaigashima" — the island of exile in one of the most tragic episodes of the Tale of the Heike, that of the monk Shunkan. Of the three men banished for their part in a plot to overthrow the Taira clan, only two were permitted to board the pardon ship. This is the story of the monk left behind, alone, on a volcanic island far from the capital.

Shunkan, left alone on a beach overlooking Mt. Io-dake

The story

The Shishigatani Conspiracy, and one man left behind.

In 1177, near the end of the Heian period, a plot to overthrow the Taira clan led by Taira no Kiyomori was uncovered at a villa in Shishigatani, Kyoto (the Shishigatani Conspiracy). Three men involved in the plan — the monk Shunkan, Fujiwara no Naritsune, and Taira no Yasuyori — were captured and exiled to Kikaigashima, a remote island far south of the capital. Despite having once held the high rank of sozu (a senior Buddhist cleric), Shunkan was forced to endure a punishing life as an exile on a desolate island wreathed in volcanic smoke.

The following year, 1178, a general amnesty granted to mark the safe delivery of the empress's child brought pardons for Naritsune and Yasuyori, and a ship arrived at Kikaigashima to bring them home. But Shunkan's name alone was missing from the pardon document. Clinging to the boat on the shore, Shunkan begged not to be left behind, but the ship departed regardless, leaving him alone on the island. This scene — "Shunkan, left alone on the island" — is one of the most celebrated passages in the Tale of the Heike, later staged repeatedly as the Noh and Kabuki play "Shunkan," and it has moved audiences to tears ever since.

Between story and history: The historical fact that Shunkan was exiled to Kikaigashima is recorded in sources beyond the Tale of the Heike, but the scene of him clinging to the departing ship may have been heavily embellished for literary effect. The Tale of the Heike is a war chronicle, not a history book, and it's worth keeping in mind that fact and literary invention are intertwined throughout it.

Where is "Kikaigashima," really?

Iwo-jima, or somewhere else?

There are actually several theories about which present-day island corresponds to the "Kikaigashima" described in the Tale of the Heike. The most widely favored candidate is Iwo-jima — part of the outer rim of the Kikai Caldera, now Iwo-jima, Mishima Village, Kagoshima District — where a "Monument to Shunkan" and "Shunkan-do," a hall said to enshrine him, still stand today. But a long-standing rival theory points instead to Kikai Island, further south (now Kikai Town, Oshima District), rather than Satsuma Iwo-jima — a claim bolstered by the similarity between the names "Kikaigashima" (鬼界ヶ島) and "Kikai Island" (喜界島) — and the two islands still, in a sense, compete for the "real" title today.

Mishima Village's position: Mishima Village treasures the tradition that Iwo-jima is the traditional site of the Tale of the Heike's Kikaigashima as part of its local history, and actively works to preserve and promote the historic sites associated with Shunkan. That said, this is understood as a "traditional site," not an academically confirmed, singular identification — a point local materials themselves acknowledge.

Iwo-jima is also one of the islands with its own legends of Taira clan survivors (ochudo). Tradition holds that remnants of the defeated Taira clan, after their loss at the Battle of Dan-no-ura, fled all the way to this remote volcanic island and settled there — layering the memory of the Taira clan's glory and downfall, alongside Shunkan's tragedy, onto this small island many times over.

Next up

From a tragic tale to a romantic myth.

Kagoshima is home not only to tragedies like Shunkan's, but also to a place that claims to be the birthplace of a beloved fairy tale about longing for the Dragon Palace. We introduce the legend of Urashima Taro, associated with Nagasakibana, the cape at the southern tip of the Satsuma Peninsula.

Read about Nagasakibana & the Dragon Palace →
Advertisement Ad space (AdSense pending)